Home > Index > Effect of shield size on block and guard
TEST RESULTS
Effect of shield size on block and guard


Tester     
Date     
March 23 – 26, 2011
Version     
Release 1.108
Server     
Pendragon and Gaheris

Summary

Three crafted shields (one of each size) were compared in four separate experiments:

  • Blocking for self against a level 75 test mob on Pendragon.
  • Blocking for self against ten red/purple mobs (Breifine finliaths) on Gaheris.
  • Guarding another toon against a level 75 test mob on Pendragon.
  • Guarding another toon against ten red/purple mobs (Breifine finliaths) on Gaheris.

Against multiple enemies, the large shield worked best. Against a single enemy, the large and medium shields tied. The small shield performed worst.


Results

Table 1. Results
Experiment
Shield size
Successes Chances Rate (%) 95% Confidence Interval (%)
Block for self against one level-75 test mob Large 894 1037 86.21 ± 2.10
Medium 881 1029 85.62 ± 2.14
Small 1453 1813 80.14 ± 1.84
Block for self against ten red/purple mobs Large 2714 3869 70.15 ± 1.44
Medium 2327 3805 61.16 ± 1.55
Small 1998 3776 52.91 ± 1.59
Guard another toon against one level-75 test mob Large 3955 4629 85.44 ± 1.02
Medium 4051 4666 86.82 ± 0.97
Small 3687 4626 79.70 ± 1.16
Guard another toon against ten red/purple mobs Large 1519 1528 99.41 ± 0.38
Medium 1432 1568 91.33 ± 1.39
Small 1337 1682 79.49 ± 1.93

Methods

Results were computed by parsing chat logs with Mojo.

Three crafted shields were used. Their stats were identical except for size and speed. They were level 51 and 99% quality. All measurements were made with the same toon wearing the same equipment. The toon was a Saracen pally with 50+17 shield, mastery of blocking IX, a greater barricading mythirian, augmented dexterity IX, and 10 points of PvE block bonus. The toon's buffed dexterity was 383.

The experiments against a single enemy were done with the Thrust test mob on Alb Pendragon. The mob was told to use a large shield and set itself to level 75. The experiments against ten enemies were done at the Breifine finliaths camp on Gaheris. All ten finliaths were aggroed on a single toon and kept alive for the duration of the test.

Before each test of a shield, the shield and armor were repaired to 100 percent.


Tests with ten mobs were done by stacking ten finliaths on a single toon. The toon didn't use a weapon, so the same ten mobs remained alive for the duration of the test. In this screenshot, a pally blocks for hmself with a small shield.

Many thanks to Gostond and Torianna of Gaheris for their help.

This page was last revised on March 26, 2011.
Copyright 2010 Robbie of Gaheris